Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for declining my friend's father's funeral because of how he treated me?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked me to sit beside her at her father's funeral. I said I didn't think I could attend.

When we were teenagers, he repeatedly mocked my family and eventually told her not to bring me to their house. She knows what happened. We stayed friends separately from him, and I hadn't seen him for years before he died.

She says she isn't asking me to praise or forgive him. She wants someone she trusts beside her during a difficult day. I understand that distinction, but I don't want to spend the service listening to tributes and acting as though my own history has disappeared.

I offered to be with her the evening before and help afterward. She said those offers were kind but weren't the support she'd asked for.

I'm not relieved about her loss or trying to punish her for his behavior. AITA for declining when attending could be about her rather than him?

Discussion

5 community replies

She made a specific request because she wants you nearby. You can take that need seriously without concluding that your own history is irrelevant to whether you can meet it.

Tell her you aren't asking her to share your account of him or to grieve differently. That may help distinguish your absence from a judgment about her relationship with her father.

Keep the offers before and afterward available if you genuinely want to make them. Don't present them as proof that she shouldn't feel disappointed about the service itself.

Attending a funeral can be an act of support for the person beside you, rather than an endorsement of the person who died. I understand her asking.

It can, and the narrator might consider whether quiet attendance would feel possible on that basis. It doesn't mean every person with a painful history has to find that distinction sufficient. The request deserves thought, rather than an automatic yes or a dismissal of her need.

Join the discussion

More in AITA