Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for cutting my friend's jokes from the toast we'd written together?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend reached a marked pause in our joint toast, looked down and realised the joke she'd written wasn't there.

We were speaking at our friends' anniversary dinner. We'd drafted it together. I offered to put the final copy into a readable format, then spent the evening changing lines I thought were awkward and removing most of her jokes.

I didn't send the revision back. I thought we were short of time, and that discussing every cut would make the piece longer again. We saw each other just before speaking, when I handed her the printed pages.

She got through her parts, but afterwards said she'd effectively been asked to perform a version of our work she hadn't agreed to. I said I had kept the important memories and made it flow better.

She says even if every edit were an improvement, I wasn't the sole editor and she should have known what she'd be reading. I'm still attached to the version I made. I'm less sure why I thought that entitled me to surprise the person standing beside me.

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA for withholding the revision. Whether your jokes were better isn't the main question when she was about to read the script with you. Formatting wasn't an agreement that you'd make the final creative decisions alone.

Time pressure explains why discussing the cuts felt inconvenient. It doesn't explain why sending the finished version for her to see was impossible. You removed even the chance for her to prepare.

You don't have to pretend you prefer the original draft. You can apologise for the process while still thinking the changes worked. She isn't asking you to prove your taste was wrong.

If you collaborate again, decide who can make final cuts and when both speakers will see the script. Keep that agreement small enough to follow rather than promising never to edit anything without a meeting.

Right—the lesson is shared awareness and authority, not a ban on editing. A quick agreed revision is very different from handing somebody a changed speech as they go up to deliver it.

Join the discussion

More in AITA