Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for congratulating my friend privately instead of commenting on her public announcement?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend announced that her first art exhibition had been confirmed. I sent a long message saying how proud I was and asking which night I should come. She replied warmly.

A few days later, she asked why I hadn't commented on the announcement. She said seeing close friends publicly celebrate it mattered to her, especially when acquaintances had made the effort.

I said I'd already congratulated her directly. She pointed out that I'd commented on a mutual friend's funny photo that week, so this wasn't a general refusal to use the platform. That's true. I just don't usually think of a public comment as part of responding to important news.

When she kept explaining, I said, “I don't perform friendship for an audience.” She said that made her wish for visible support sound shallow. I can see why it landed that way.

I'm planning to attend and haven't withdrawn my offer to help set up. AITA for not adding a public congratulations once she asked?

Discussion

5 community replies

Your private message was real support. The line about performing friendship was an unnecessary judgment of how she likes to celebrate.

Once she asked, a short sincere comment seems like a small kindness if you're comfortable making one. You don't have to believe public congratulations are essential to understand why she wanted yours.

Attending the exhibition and offering setup help shouldn't become evidence in a contest over which form of support is best. Tell her what you are happy to do, and listen to why this particular missing piece hurt.

I'd hesitate to make public comments something friends must request and then check off. That could turn an affectionate gesture into another obligation.

Before treating this as a standing rule, I'd ask whether that's what she wants. Her first exhibition may be a celebration where visible congratulations matter to her more than on ordinary posts.

Join the discussion

More in AITA