Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for collecting everyone's meal money before I place our group order?

AITA category photographAITA

I put the menu down and said I'd order once everyone had sent their share.

For months I've placed the takeaway order for our Friday group. Usually I pay first and people send their amounts afterward. Most do it that evening. A few payments need reminders, and I've occasionally let small differences go because chasing them feels worse than losing the money.

This week I asked everyone to pay before I submitted the order. One friend said it made a relaxed evening feel like a checkout queue. Another asked whether I thought they couldn't be trusted.

I said I didn't want to be the person keeping track after everyone had gone home. They offered to send the money later as usual, which was exactly the arrangement I wanted to change.

I should have mentioned the new plan before we all arrived hungry. It took another fifteen minutes to settle the amounts and send them. Nobody missed out on food, but I spent dinner being asked whether their payment had been sufficiently prompt.

AITA for changing the routine for everyone because a few people had made the old version tedious?

Discussion

5 community replies

You were changing a task you perform, not issuing a verdict on every friend's honesty. Paying first and then tracking repayments is part of the work, even when each individual reminder seems small.

The late announcement created avoidable friction. A message earlier in the day could have let everyone arrive ready to choose and pay. You can own that timing without returning to an arrangement you dislike.

Someone who thinks the old way is easier could offer to place and fund the order. That would test whether the convenience was truly shared or was mostly yours to provide.

Applying the same routine to everyone may be less awkward than naming a shortlist of slow payers. The friends who already paid promptly haven't necessarily lost much beyond the few minutes of setup.

Yes, but keep the explanation with simplifying the task rather than making prompt friends defend themselves. The later jokes about payment may fade if the narrator stops arguing about who deserves the rule and simply makes the ordering arrangement clear beforehand.

Join the discussion

More in AITA