Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for closing our front door when my roommate leaves it open to chat with neighbors?

AITA category photographAITA

My roommate propped our front door open while she cooked. I came home, took off my work clothes, and closed it. She opened it again because she was talking to someone across the hall.

She likes the building to feel sociable. If the door is open, neighbors stop for a chat and sometimes step into the living room. I like several of them, but I don't always want to be visible from the corridor or ready to receive people at home.

We hadn't discussed the open-door habit before moving in. I've now asked that she invite people in when she wants company and otherwise keep the door closed. She says that's the same result, except making her home feel less welcoming for no reason. I said there's a difference between an invited visitor and whoever happens to see me eating on the sofa.

Yesterday I closed it while she was mid-conversation. She says I embarrassed her by making it obvious I wanted the neighbor to go. I could have waited, but I didn't want another evening with the corridor watching our living room.

AITA for making this a closed-door household?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for wanting privacy in the shared living room. Your roommate can be friendly without making the entire flat available to passing conversations.

Closing it mid-sentence sent a message to the neighbor who wasn't part of your disagreement. I'd apologize for the awkward moment while continuing the conversation about how visitors are invited.

Would you be comfortable with her saying, “Come in for ten minutes,” or do you also want a warning before visitors enter? Be specific. Otherwise you may agree about the door and discover you're still disagreeing about guests.

She lives there too. An absolute rule that the door can never be open might go further than what's needed, especially if she's standing there talking.

Fair, but the narrator is describing evenings of an open view into the living room, not a greeting at the threshold. They could distinguish a brief doorway conversation from keeping the shared space open as a standing invitation.

Join the discussion

More in AITA