Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for choosing the group photo where I look best after my friend asked me to use another one?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend sent three group photos from our trip and wrote, “Please use the last one if you're posting. My eyes are doing something weird in the first.”

I posted the first because I liked how I looked. I thought she looked fine. In her choice I was mid-sentence; in the middle shot we both looked okay.

Everyone had agreed we could post group photos. She wasn't objecting to being included. When she asked why I'd ignored the message, I said she was too critical of herself and nobody would notice her expression. She pointed out that I'd noticed my own expression enough to avoid her choice.

I swapped the photo when she asked, but said it was an unreasonable amount of discussion for a holiday picture. She says that spoiled the gesture.

AITA for choosing the shot I liked for my own album?

Discussion

5 community replies

She noticed your double standard. Her expression was supposedly too trivial to worry about; yours determined which picture you posted. YTA.

The middle photo was sitting right there. This wasn't a choice between showing yourself badly and hiding her completely. You could have used the acceptable compromise or asked whether she minded you cropping a separate picture of yourself.

Swapping it was good. Calling the discussion unreasonable kept the argument alive. You could have stopped after “You're right, I chose the one that flattered me.”

I don't think one friend should get final approval of every picture in somebody else's album. That can turn sharing a trip into a lot of administration.

Neither do I, but this wasn't an open-ended approval process. She supplied three shots and one clear request before the post went up. Ignoring that particular message is what made the administration happen afterward.

Join the discussion

More in AITA