Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for capping the money my son could keep after he counted my jar of coins?

AITA category photographAITA

I told my twelve-year-old he could keep the change in an old jar if he counted and sorted it. I expected a few dollars. It came to $74.

When he showed me the total, I said I hadn't meant that much and offered him $20 instead. He said I hadn't mentioned a limit. He'd spent part of the afternoon sorting the coins and making a careful note of the amounts.

The money is mine from years of emptying pockets. I can afford to let him have it; I just felt startled by how much a casual promise had turned into. His sister gets smaller amounts for occasional extra jobs, and I said this wouldn't be fair to her. He pointed out that she hadn't been given the same offer.

My partner thinks I should keep the promise and be clearer next time. I think parents should be able to correct an overgenerous offer once they understand it. AITA for changing the amount after the counting was done?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the offer you actually made. You can afford it, the work is done, and the only surprise is that the jar held more than you guessed.

The fairness argument doesn't fit very well. His sister's separate jobs had separate offers. You can explain that this was a one-off mistake without reducing what he was told he'd receive.

If you'd wanted to pay for counting, you could have named a fee. Instead you offered the contents. Those are different deals, and he completed the one you described.

Parents do need room to correct mistaken promises. I wouldn't want a rule where every casual sentence has to be followed literally regardless of the consequences.

Neither would I. But the narrator says this is affordable and the problem is feeling startled. That makes honoring this particular promise quite different from carrying out an offer that would seriously harm the household.

Join the discussion

More in AITA