Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for buying different birthday gifts for my sister's twins?

AITA category photographAITA

One of my nephews opened a model train set. His twin opened a drawing kit and asked why he hadn't got a train too.

They're eight. I'd chosen the gifts after hearing one talk about trains and the other show me drawings he was proud of. I spent the same amount on each, but the boxes looked very different. I knew my sister usually bought matching presents. I thought choosing separately would show that I'd listened to each boy.

My sister asked privately whether I could exchange the drawing kit for another train set. I said I'd chosen it for him and didn't want to replace a thoughtful gift just because his brother's looked more exciting at that moment.

She said she was the one dealing with the disappointment, and that I could have checked with her before testing a different birthday arrangement. I offered to draw with him later, but she said that wasn't what she'd asked.

I don't think the boys have to receive identical things forever. I'm less sure that their birthday was my occasion to make that point. AITA for refusing the exchange?

Discussion

5 community replies

The separate choices were thoughtful. Your refusal to reconsider is less thoughtful. The child has now told you what he wanted, and keeping the gift unchanged doesn't prove you understand him better than the train he actually asked for.

Your sister's matching-gift habit isn't automatically a rule every relative must follow. But you knew the usual arrangement and deliberately tried something else without asking. Own that choice instead of making her disappointment sound like opposition to treating the boys as individuals.

Equal spending doesn't make two presents equally appealing to the children opening them. Don't bring the price comparison into the conversation with the boys; it won't answer why one wants a train.

Would the drawing kit still be useful to him another time? If an exchange is possible and you're willing, you could give him the train now and let future gifts follow what he actually asks for, rather than defending the first choice as a statement about individuality.

I'd avoid making the drawing kit a deferred lesson he has to appreciate later. If you exchange it, let that be the end of the dispute. He can enjoy drawing and also want the same train as his brother on this birthday.

Join the discussion

More in AITA