AITA for buying different birthday gifts for my sister's twins?
AITAOne of my nephews opened a model train set. His twin opened a drawing kit and asked why he hadn't got a train too.
They're eight. I'd chosen the gifts after hearing one talk about trains and the other show me drawings he was proud of. I spent the same amount on each, but the boxes looked very different. I knew my sister usually bought matching presents. I thought choosing separately would show that I'd listened to each boy.
My sister asked privately whether I could exchange the drawing kit for another train set. I said I'd chosen it for him and didn't want to replace a thoughtful gift just because his brother's looked more exciting at that moment.
She said she was the one dealing with the disappointment, and that I could have checked with her before testing a different birthday arrangement. I offered to draw with him later, but she said that wasn't what she'd asked.
I don't think the boys have to receive identical things forever. I'm less sure that their birthday was my occasion to make that point. AITA for refusing the exchange?