Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for backing out of my friend's plan to test her boyfriend with a flirty message?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend sent me the message she wanted me to send her boyfriend. I read it, then told her I wouldn't do it after all.

She suspects he's flirting with other people. I haven't seen evidence myself; she's told me about things that make her uneasy. When she first asked whether I'd help find out, I said yes because she was upset. I didn't ask what helping meant.

Her plan was for me to message him from my own account as though I was interested in him and see how he answered. They both know me. She said that made it a better test because he couldn't dismiss it as a message from a stranger.

I said I didn't want to pretend to pursue him or make his next conversation with me part of an investigation. She said I'd promised to help and was now more concerned about his comfort than hers.

I offered to talk through what she'd noticed, but wouldn't send the message. I haven't warned him or told anyone else about her plan. AITA for saying yes before thinking and then withdrawing when she was counting on me?

Discussion

5 community replies

You agreed too quickly, but you corrected that before sending anything. Helping a friend doesn't have to mean carrying out a particular deception once you learn what it involves.

Apologise for the careless yes. She may have heard that as finally having someone willing to stand beside her, then felt dropped when you read the plan. You can acknowledge that disappointment while keeping your refusal.

This would also put your own relationship with him into a false position. You're not a neutral instrument she can use to collect a response. You're the person whose account and apparent intentions he would be responding to.

Keep any offer of help concrete and within what you actually want to do: listen to the incidents she's concerned about or help her work out what she wants to ask him. Don't offer a vague “anything else” that starts the same promise problem again.

And don't promise that a direct conversation will settle whether he's faithful. It may help her understand what she wants or what he says, but you can't guarantee certainty through a different method. Your refusal doesn't need a replacement investigation that works better.

Join the discussion

More in AITA