Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking to change the room payments when I give up the ground-floor bedroom?

AITA category photographAITA

I said I'd move upstairs so a new guest could have the ground-floor bedroom, but I wanted us to revisit what everyone paid. A friend replied, “Why are you putting a price on access?”

Our group had booked a holiday house and divided the cost according to the rooms we'd chosen. I'd agreed to pay more for the larger bedroom with its own bathroom. After a guest with an upstairs room canceled, the organizer invited another friend to take her place. She said she couldn't manage the stairs.

I don't want her excluded, and I'm willing to move. The upstairs room I'd use is smaller and shares a bathroom. I don't think I should keep paying the original higher share after changing rooms.

I'm not asking the new guest to cover the difference by herself. I asked the group to work out the allocation again. The organizer says the booking cost hasn't changed and we're making an awkward issue out of a straightforward accommodation.

AITA for agreeing to the swap with that financial condition attached?

Discussion

5 community replies

The house's total cost and each person's share are separate questions. You can support the room swap while asking the group to recognize that the original allocation no longer describes the rooms people have.

Keep the discussion with the organizer about the group arrangement, rather than making the new guest explain or defend her access needs. She didn't set your original room price.

Ask the organizer to propose revised shares for the whole group, rather than leaving it as a negotiation between you and the new guest. Then everyone can say what they can actually afford under the changed arrangement.

Someone has to absorb the difference, and the others may have budgeted around their original shares too. It isn't automatically easy for everyone else to pay more.

That's true, which is why the whole group needs to discuss it. It doesn't follow that the person changing rooms should silently absorb all of it. The organizer changed the guest list after the initial allocation and now has a planning problem to resolve.

Join the discussion

More in AITA