Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking someone else to critique my story after my friend had already spent hours on it?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend saw my revised short story and asked why I'd undone the change she'd suggested.

I said another reader thought the original opening worked better. She replied, “Then why did I spend Saturday on it?”

She'd offered to read the draft and gave detailed comments. I thanked her, used several suggestions and sent the revision to another friend whose opinion I also value. I didn't forward her notes or ask the second person to judge her. I asked what they thought of the story.

Now she says I kept looking until someone told me what I wanted to hear. I did prefer the original opening, but I also wanted another perspective before choosing.

I hadn't promised her final say. I can still see why learning I'd reversed a suggestion after she put in so much effort felt dismissive. AITA for seeking another opinion without telling her first?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA for asking another reader. Critique gives you information to consider; it doesn't make every suggested change a commitment you must preserve.

She may be reacting to hearing only about the advice you reversed. Tell her which comments helped you, if you haven't already. Specific thanks would be more meaningful than saying all feedback is valuable.

Check your own reason for the second read. Wanting another perspective is fair; collecting opinions only until you can defend the version you already wanted is less open-minded. Neither means she gets final control of the draft.

For another round, be clear whether you want one person's detailed editing or several readers' reactions before revising. That helps people decide how much effort they want to offer.

And you can set that expectation without turning readers into voters. If three people prefer an opening and you choose the other one, it is still your choice to explain—not a tally they were promised would decide it.

Join the discussion

More in AITA