Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my partner not to wear a necklace from her ex to our anniversary dinner?

AITA category photographAITA

I recognized the necklace as she put it on and asked whether she could choose something else for the evening.

Her ex gave it to her years before we met. It's a small blue pendant she wears occasionally, and I've never asked her not to wear it generally. For our anniversary dinner, I suddenly wanted the evening to feel separate from earlier relationships.

She said she'd chosen it because it went with her clothes and hadn't been thinking about the person who bought it. I said I understood, but that knowing its history made it hard for me to see it the same way.

She changed the necklace, then was quiet over dinner. Later she said the request made an ordinary possession feel like evidence she wasn't fully present with me. I said it had been one evening, not a demand to get rid of anything.

She asked whether she was now supposed to check the origin of every item before a special occasion. I don't want that. I wanted a small reassurance, but I may have made her wardrobe responsible for a feeling I hadn't explained until we were leaving. AITA?

Discussion

5 community replies

The necklace had a meaning for you that she says wasn't part of her choice. She told you she chose the color. Your association alone doesn't establish that she was bringing the ex into the dinner deliberately.

A one-evening request is narrower than asking her to discard it, but it still affected her. Her changing the necklace doesn't necessarily mean the request felt easy or affectionate.

Talk about what reassurance you actually wanted. If it was hearing that the evening mattered to her, an object change may have been a poor substitute for that conversation.

Would you feel reassured if she chose another necklace freely after understanding your feeling, or only if she agreed the original was inappropriate? Those are different things to ask from her.

If agreement about its meaning is the requirement, the problem will outlast the dinner. The narrator can own the association without asking the partner to adopt it. That may leave more room for future occasions than turning each item's history into a test.

Join the discussion

More in AITA