Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my left-handed friend to move seats after I chose the corner she wanted?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend asked for the corner seat at dinner because eating beside me can mean our elbows knock. I wanted the corner because it had a view of the room, and I sat there first.

Once the food arrived, we did keep bumping arms. I asked her to move around to the next side of the table. She said I should swap with her instead, as she'd suggested before we ordered.

I didn't want to change seats halfway through the meal. She replied that I'd chosen the arrangement and was now asking her to solve its predictable problem by sitting farther from the people she'd been talking to.

The table was crowded but not fixed; swapping the two of us was possible. I said being left-handed shouldn't give someone permanent first choice at every dinner. She said she was asking about this table, not announcing a lifelong rule.

AITA for expecting her to make the adjustment this time?

Discussion

5 community replies

YTA in this particular seating dispute. She raised the elbow problem before the meal, and swapping you two would have addressed it without sending her away from the conversation.

You're arguing against a permanent entitlement she didn't claim. If another table works differently, you can discuss that table then. It doesn't answer what happened at this one.

The view mattered to you, and avoiding repeated contact mattered to her. Now you've seen the contact actually happening, it seems reasonable to reconsider rather than treat sitting down first as the final decision.

I don't think left-handed guests should automatically dictate the seating. Other people may have preferences or needs that aren't immediately visible.

Agreed, and those could be discussed if raised. Here the narrator describes a preferred view, an actual elbow clash, and a simple swap. The broader possibility of other needs doesn't outweigh the details they've given.

Join the discussion

More in AITA