Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my friend to stop estimating the nutrition in my lunch?

AITA category photographAITA

“My lunch isn't a progress report,” I said when my friend started estimating what was on my plate. She put her phone away and barely spoke for the rest of the meal.

She's interested in tracking her food and training. I enjoy hearing about things she's working toward, and we've discussed meals she likes making. Lately, though, our lunches often include estimates about my order and suggestions about how she'd change it.

I haven't asked for that. When I said so earlier, she replied that she was talking about the food, not judging my body. I believe that's how she sees it. I still don't want my meals assessed.

This time another friend was with us. She says I could have simply changed the subject rather than using a line that made her sound controlling. I said I'd already tried explaining the preference privately.

AITA for drawing the distinction publicly instead of letting one more comment pass?

Discussion

5 community replies

You had already asked her not to assess your meals. She doesn't need to intend a judgment about your body for the running commentary to be unwelcome.

The progress-report line was sharp, but it also captured the difference between sharing her interest and making your lunch part of it. You can soften the delivery without withdrawing that distinction.

Offer a clear alternative if you want: you're happy to hear about a recipe she enjoys, but not estimates or proposed changes to your own order. That gives her something more precise than guessing which food conversations are safe.

I'd struggle if a friend seemed to ban talking about food while we were out eating. It's a normal part of having lunch together.

The request can be narrower than a ban on food conversation. Taste, recipes, and what she enjoys aren't the same as repeatedly assessing the narrator's plate. That narrower boundary seems worth keeping clear.

Join the discussion

More in AITA