Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my friend to cover the tip after she volunteered me for a street performer's act?

AITA category photographAITA

The performer asked for a volunteer, and my friend pointed at me and shouted my name. Everyone looked over. I went forward rather than make a fuss.

The act was harmless: I held a prop, repeated a ridiculous line, and got a round of applause. I was embarrassed at first but did end up laughing. At the end, the performer held out a hat, mentioned a suggested contribution, and looked at me. I put in $10 because I felt awkward being the volunteer who walked away.

As we left, I asked my friend to send me the money. She thought I was joking. I said I wouldn't have gone up or felt pressured to pay if she hadn't put me on the spot.

She says she'd only nominated me, I could have refused, and paying was my decision. She also says asking afterward turns a funny ten minutes into an invoice. I told her beforehand that I don't like audience participation, though I hadn't specifically said not to point at me that day.

I haven't chased the money again. AITA for thinking the person who volunteered me should cover the contribution I made?

Discussion

5 community replies

ESH a little. Your friend knew you dislike being singled out and did it anyway. But you chose an amount afterward without asking her. I'd focus the repair on “don't volunteer me again” rather than treating the $10 as an agreed expense.

I can understand asking her to cover it as a gesture. She created the awkward situation, even if she didn't control what you paid. She can decline, but dismissing the whole issue as spoiling a joke doesn't address that part.

Enjoying the act by the end doesn't mean you were happy to be volunteered. Say that clearly, so the fact that you laughed doesn't become a reason to brush off your request next time.

How did she respond when you told her earlier that you dislike audience participation? If she agreed not to volunteer you, this includes a broken promise. If it was a passing preference, I'd still expect her to take it seriously now.

That would change how pointedly I'd address her choice. In either case, I'd separate the request to cover $10 from the clearer request not to nominate the narrator again. Refusing the payment shouldn't become permission to repeat the setup.

Join the discussion

More in AITA