Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my friend's cleaner about extra pay in front of the dinner guests?

AITA category photographAITA

“Are you being paid extra for tonight?” I asked the woman clearing our plates. My friend was sitting beside me.

My friend had said she'd asked her regular cleaner to stay longer to help with the dinner party. I wondered whether that extra work was being recognized. I didn't know their arrangement.

The cleaner replied that it was between her and my friend, then took the plates away. My friend later said I'd put an employee on the spot in front of her employer and a table of guests.

I said I didn't want everyone to enjoy the evening without considering the person doing the work. She replied that I'd considered it by asking that person to explain private pay arrangements publicly.

I hadn't heard a complaint or seen anything that established she wasn't being paid for the extra time. I also don't want concern about politeness to mean nobody can question how people are treated.

AITA for asking directly rather than leaving it alone?

Discussion

5 community replies

The worker's answer is the clearest part of this account: she didn't want that discussion at the table. Start by respecting that, rather than treating her as the witness needed to prove your concern was worthwhile.

You knew she'd stayed longer; you didn't know what had been arranged. Asking your friend about the plans privately would have avoided requiring the employee to answer in front of her.

If you apologize, don't turn it into another request for details about her pay. You can simply acknowledge that you put her in a difficult social position without asking whether she wanted the conversation.

Awkward questions can sometimes expose problems people would otherwise prefer guests not to notice. I wouldn't make comfort the only consideration.

Neither would I. But an awkward question can also fall hardest on the person with less room to respond. Here there wasn't an established problem to challenge, and the narrator made the employee's pay the public test.

Join the discussion

More in AITA