Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my friend not to use an old photo of me in her transformation video?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend sent me a preview of her video with the caption, “We really let ourselves go back then.” I asked her to take out the photograph that included me.

The video is about changes she's proud of making in her own life. The picture is an old one of us together, and I'd shared it online before. I like it as a memory. I don't like being placed beside her current photographs as part of a before-and-after judgment.

She says she wasn't commenting on me, and the old picture is part of her history too. I said she could tell her story without using my appearance to illustrate the starting point.

She offered to change the caption but wants to keep the image. I still asked her to choose another one. I'm not asking her to delete her private copy or stop feeling proud of herself. AITA for limiting a use she thinks the original sharing already made okay?

Discussion

5 community replies

NTA. Enjoying an old photograph doesn't mean you want it used to demonstrate a period somebody now describes negatively. The new caption and sequence change what the image is doing.

Her pride in her own changes doesn't need to be the thing you argue against. Keep explaining that your objection is appearing in that comparison, not her deciding how to describe herself.

Changing the caption was a real attempt to respond. You can thank her for that while explaining why the surrounding before-and-after format still makes you uncomfortable.

Would an image of her on her own serve the same part of the story? You don't have to produce the replacement, but keeping the request about the particular image may help avoid a dispute about who gets to remember the past.

And if she doesn't have another image she likes, that is disappointing for the edit, not proof you should accept this use. You can both value the same memory while wanting different things done with its photograph.

Join the discussion

More in AITA