Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my daughter not to correct my excuse when we arrived late to her lesson?

AITA category photographAITA

"Traffic was awful," I told the instructor.

My thirteen-year-old said, "We left late because you couldn't find your keys."

That was mostly why we were late. There had been traffic too, but I had spent fifteen minutes looking for keys I'd left in a coat. I gave the traffic explanation because I was embarrassed and didn't want to tell the whole story in front of the other families.

On the way home I asked my daughter not to contradict me like that. She said she'd only corrected what happened. I replied that family members don't need to volunteer every unflattering detail about one another.

She asked whether that meant she was supposed to help me blame something else. I said there was a difference between lying and keeping private details private, but I wasn't sure my original sentence fit the distinction as neatly as I wanted.

The instructor hadn't blamed my daughter or asked for a full explanation. I could simply have apologized for arriving late.

AITA for asking her to keep that detail to herself, even though I had chosen an incomplete excuse first?

Discussion

5 community replies

You were allowed to keep the key search brief. You could have done that with 'Sorry we're late' rather than making traffic sound like the main cause. Your daughter noticed the gap you now acknowledge.

A family member doesn't need to narrate every embarrassing moment publicly. That is a reasonable idea to discuss with her, but it becomes muddled if the example is a misleading excuse you want her to protect.

Tell her the late arrival was your responsibility. That would take away any suggestion that correcting you made her responsible for the awkwardness. You can discuss tact after owning what you said.

The useful distinction is between declining to give details and asking someone to support the explanation you chose instead. Those aren't quite the same request.

That gives the parent a clearer answer to the daughter's question. They can say the key story didn't need a public retelling, while admitting that blaming traffic created the opening for correction. The lesson needn't be that a parent's version must go unchallenged.

Join the discussion

More in AITA