Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking my comedian friend to remove my name from a story we'd worked on together?

AITA category photographAITA

My friend sent me the running order for his comedy set. The bit about me walking into the wrong wedding reception was still there, with my real first name.

We'd worked on the story together and I'd said he could perform it. He used my name in rehearsal, and I didn't object then. I knew it would be a public show, though I hadn't thought much about who might attend.

Now two people from my new workplace have said they're going. I'm suddenly uncomfortable being the person attached to the mistake. I asked him to change the name and a couple of identifying details a week before the show.

He says the details make the story work and he already built the transitions around them. He also says I enjoyed helping shape the jokes until I realized people I wanted to impress might hear them.

That's true. My concern has changed, rather than him breaking an earlier agreement. I don't want to forbid the story, but I want less of my identity in it. AITA for asking him to revise it after I'd approved the material?

Discussion

5 community replies

You're allowed to ask after realizing what the audience could mean for you. Start by acknowledging that he relied on your earlier approval. This is a request to revise an agreement, not proof that he ignored one.

Which identifying details are essential to the joke, and which merely make it recognizable to mutual friends? Going through those together could be more productive than demanding the whole bit become vague.

He may feel as though the story is now being judged by whether your colleagues approve of you. Reassure him that you still like the material if that's true. Your new discomfort doesn't have to become criticism of his work.

Changing only the first name may not stop the colleagues recognizing the story. Has the narrator thought about what level of privacy the requested edits would actually achieve?

That's worth discussing before he does the revisions. The useful goal is to reduce the details the narrator is uncomfortable sharing, with a realistic understanding that mutual acquaintances might still recognize the event. A name swap needn't be sold as a guarantee.

Join the discussion

More in AITA