Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
AITA · Advice & Questions ·

AITA for asking friends to keep their presents out of sight at my no-gifts birthday brunch?

AITA category photographAITA

I met them at the door and said, quietly, "Could you leave the bags in the car?"

I'd invited eight friends for birthday brunch and specifically asked them not to bring presents. I wanted everyone to arrive without comparing what they'd spent or whether they'd remembered to buy something. Two friends arrived carrying wrapped books.

They said they had found things I'd like and wanted to give them to me with everyone there. I asked whether we could exchange them another day. One friend said I was treating a kind thought like a breach of party rules.

They put the bags in the car and came back in. The brunch went ahead, but the doorway exchange was still on my mind. Later I thanked them for thinking of me, but said I hadn't wanted a present-opening moment when other people had followed the request.

They say I assumed the other guests would feel embarrassed and made the people who brought gifts feel embarrassed instead. Nobody else has told me the lack of presents was a problem.

I meant to take pressure out of the occasion. I may have created a different sort of pressure at the door. AITA for insisting the surprise gifts stay private?

Discussion

5 community replies

Your invitation was specific, and the other guests had reason to rely on it. Asking not to have a public opening was consistent with the kind of gathering you had described, not a rule invented after seeing the books.

The friends could still feel their affection was being treated as a problem. Thanking them clearly matters. That doesn't mean they needed the group audience in order for the gift to be received warmly.

Don't claim to know that the other guests would have been ashamed. You can say you wanted the request to remain meaningful and didn't want a presentation, without assigning feelings to people who haven't expressed them.

Could accepting the bags unopened have achieved the same aim with less doorway awkwardness? Keeping gifts in a bag until later is different from asking someone to walk back to the car.

That sounds like a useful distinction. The narrator could preserve the no-opening plan while making the arrival feel welcoming. It doesn't require agreeing to a gift ceremony, and it doesn't require the friends to prove their generosity by displaying the books to everyone.

Join the discussion

More in AITA