Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

A senior colleague called a junior's draft lazy in front of the room. Should I have stepped in?

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

In a project meeting, a senior colleague called a junior's draft “lazy” and asked whether she'd bothered to think about it. She went quiet. He then moved on to the next item without saying which parts needed changing.

I was there from another team and don't supervise either of them. I nearly asked us to identify the actual problems in the draft, but worried that intervening would put more attention on her. Afterwards she left before I could speak to her.

I don't know whether she wants anyone involved. I do know that I left the meeting without understanding the feedback either. What would be a useful response now, and what could I say in the room if something like that happens again without appointing myself her spokesperson?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can ask for actionable feedback on the work: “Which parts need changing, and what should they achieve?” That addresses something you also need to understand without describing the junior's feelings for her. It may be a useful way to redirect the meeting in the moment.

Check in privately if you have an appropriate way to do so. Say what you noticed and ask whether she wants to talk or needs anything for the next steps. Don't make her reassure you about not intervening, and don't promise a response on her behalf.

If you raise your own concern with the senior colleague or an appropriate manager, keep the words and context accurate. You can explain why that way of giving feedback concerned you without claiming to know a wider pattern you haven't witnessed.

Even asking a neutral question could prolong an embarrassing moment. Wouldn't waiting and supporting her afterwards sometimes be kinder?

Sometimes it may be. The in-room option is to move attention to the specific work, not stage a debate about her reaction. Afterwards, check what support she wants. You can also address your own concern about how the meeting was handled without making her responsible for deciding whether you are allowed to have one.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work