Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

A project cost was wrong after our association's ballot opened. Should voting pause?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our association has opened an anonymous member ballot to choose a community project. The comparison sheet treated one printing quote as covering the whole programme. It actually covered a single print run, so that project's comparable cost is higher than the sheet said.

Some votes have already arrived. The coordinator wants to publish a correction and keep the ballot open as planned. Another member wants to pause and restart, because we cannot tell which earlier voters relied on the incorrect figure. There is no agreed correction procedure, and restarting would ask everyone to vote again.

What would you establish before choosing a remedy? I want all members to have a fair chance to reconsider, without assuming either that the error changed every vote or that a corrected file will reach everyone who already voted.

Discussion

5 community replies

I'd first establish who can authorise a pause or restart under the association's rules. An information problem needs a response, but the coordinator shouldn't have to invent decision-making authority in the moment.

Notify all eligible members about the specific error, not just people who happen to revisit the comparison sheet. Say what the quote covered and what changed in the cost comparison.

Keep a dated account of the original figure and the correction. That would help members understand the issue without having to reconstruct which version they saw or guess whether the proposal itself changed.

If the agreed ballot method lets members replace an earlier vote, I'd consider a correction and extra time before requiring a complete restart.

That could work if an earlier ballot can genuinely be replaced without counting an additional vote. If the method doesn't allow that, extra time alone won't give earlier voters the same chance to reconsider. I'd settle that practical question before announcing the remedy.

Join the discussion

More in Politics