Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

A friend missed our civic group's deadline. Is it fair to reopen it just for them?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our civic association invited agenda proposals by Friday. A friend sent one on Sunday after a difficult week of caring responsibilities. The chair wants to accept it because it's a useful subject and "we're volunteers, not a court."

I agree we should have room for real life. I also know members who rushed to finish by Friday, and others may have decided not to submit once the deadline passed. We haven't checked whether our own rules say anything about late proposals.

This is the association's internal deadline, not an election nomination or statutory consultation deadline. What worries me is making the exception after we know who needs it.

How would you weigh flexibility against a process people can rely on, without turning my friend's circumstances into a public trial?

Discussion

5 community replies

First establish what the deadline was meant to protect: time to circulate papers, space on an agenda, or something else. That helps you consider the late proposal's practical effect as well as the fairness question.

If an extension is permitted and useful, consider offering it to everyone on clear terms. That won't undo every difference in people's circumstances, but it avoids creating a private second deadline for one member.

The useful subject needn't disappear if it can't be accepted for this meeting. Ask whether it can go to the next agenda through the normal route. Urgency should be examined rather than assumed.

I'd keep the discussion of the member's personal circumstances as limited as possible. The group can consider an approach to late submissions without asking everyone to rank whose difficult week deserves an exception.

That also makes the approach easier to use next time. Decide how a late request is considered, who can decide it, and what notice others receive, within the association's rules. Your friend's case can reveal a gap without becoming the standard against which every future person's private life is judged.

Join the discussion

More in Politics