Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

A company paid for the report supporting its proposal. How should we assess its independence?

Politics category photographPolitics

The proposed venue operator calls the visitor forecast an independent report. A separate consultancy wrote it, but the operator commissioned and paid for it.

One member of our civic group says that makes the conclusions worthless. Another says the consultant's separate business address settles independence. I don't know enough about the work to accept either shortcut.

I'd want to understand the questions the consultant was asked, the assumptions behind the forecast, and who could decide what was published. I also know our volunteer group can't independently rebuild every model it receives.

What should we ask about the commission and the analysis before giving the report weight? I don't want to hide the funding relationship or treat payment as a substitute for examining the work.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what "independent" is being used to describe: a different organisation, control over the analysis, freedom to publish, or something else. The label is too broad to answer those questions by itself.

The funding relationship is relevant context. It doesn't tell you whether a particular estimate is sound. Keep scrutiny of the commission alongside scrutiny of the assumptions and evidence.

I'd request the scope of the commission and an explanation of who approved publication. That could reveal limits in what the report was asked to examine without requiring you to allege that the conclusions were dictated.

Your group may need to identify which assumptions matter most rather than attempt a complete technical audit. Not understanding every model detail doesn't mean you must either accept the report wholesale or discard it.

Focus your questions on what drives the conclusion and what would change it. Ask for a plain explanation and identify where appropriate specialist review would be needed. You can state the limits of the group's assessment while still making the commission and its assumptions visible.

Join the discussion

More in Politics