Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

A colleague asked for my exact salary. I support fair pay, but I'm hesitating.

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A colleague at the same grade has asked what I earn so we can compare whether we're being paid fairly. I understand why she wants real figures rather than the broad salary range in the handbook.

I haven't answered yet. I'm fairly private about money, and she has mentioned putting several people's figures into a spreadsheet to discuss with the manager. She hasn't said who would have access or whether names would be attached. In a team this small, I'm not sure removing the names would make us hard to identify anyway.

I don't want her to hear my hesitation as support for unfair pay. But I also don't want to give a number and then discover I agreed to a use I wasn't comfortable with. What should I clarify before deciding, and is there a useful way to support the conversation if I choose not to share my exact salary?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask how she plans to collect, store and use the figures, who would see them and what she intends to ask the manager. You can support the purpose and still need those answers before contributing your own information.

If you're willing, you could share your figure with her directly while setting out what you are comfortable having passed on. But only do that if you accept that you won't have complete control once you've told someone. A shared aim doesn't automatically mean shared expectations about privacy.

You could help gather the published grade ranges, progression criteria and questions for the manager without adding your own number. That would be a concrete contribution rather than a vague statement that you support her.

Without actual salaries, though, the group may struggle to show what needs explaining. Would declining leave everyone else taking the personal risk while you benefit from their openness?

That's a fair cost to acknowledge when deciding, and it might persuade you to contribute under an agreed plan. It still doesn't answer who gets your figure or how it's used. You can discuss that trade-off openly with her instead of treating either disclosure or refusal as a test of loyalty.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work