Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

What does “add analysis” look like when the evidence is already on the page?

Education category photographEducation

My instructor wrote “add analysis” beside three paragraphs of my essay. I understand the words separately. Together, they feel like a locked door.

Each paragraph already has a quotation, and I explain what happens in it. When I received the draft, I tried to improve the first paragraph by adding another sentence that began, “This shows that…” The new sentence mostly repeated the quotation in plainer language. It made the paragraph longer, which briefly felt like progress.

I asked a classmate what analysis means. She said it is “the why behind the evidence.” That sounds right until I sit down to write the why. Why does the quotation matter? Because it supports my point. Why does it support my point? Because it says something similar. I can keep circling those answers without making a claim more precise.

The assignment asks us to compare how two authors present responsibility. My draft points out that both use family conflict. What I have not done is explain the difference the comparison creates. One author makes responsibility look chosen; the other makes it look inherited. That distinction is not sitting visibly in either quotation. It comes from putting them next to each other.

I think that may be the missing work.

For revision, I am trying three questions after each piece of evidence: What detail am I asking the reader to notice? What interpretation am I making of that detail? How does that interpretation change or sharpen the paragraph’s claim? If I cannot answer the third question, the quotation may be present without doing any argumentative work.

I still want to confirm that this matches what my instructor means in this course. “Analysis” may not look identical across a literature essay, a lab report, and a history paper. I plan to bring one original paragraph and one revised paragraph to office hours and ask which sentence begins to do the missing work.

The embarrassing part is that I have received versions of this comment for years. I kept treating it as a request for more words because word count is measurable. Thinking is harder to count.

How would you explain the difference between summary and analysis without using either word in the explanation? What is the smallest revision that can make the difference visible?

Discussion

3 community replies

Try a three-line test: point to one exact detail, state what you infer from it, then explain what that inference changes about your claim. If the third line repeats the first, the analysis is not finished.

Does the instructor provide a model paragraph or rubric language that shows the expected move? The most useful definition is the one attached to this assignment and discipline.

Not every quotation needs several sentences of interpretation. Sometimes the stronger revision is removing evidence that merely echoes the point and developing the example that creates a real distinction.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →