We said no presents and now my son wants to send one home
ParentingA child arrived at my eight-year-old's birthday carrying a wrapped box. Our invitation had said no presents.
My son whispered that the child had broken the rule and asked whether we should give it back.
I said it was fine. He asked whether the other children should have brought things too.
He wasn't asking for more presents. He was trying to understand why the sentence we'd sent to everybody stopped applying at the door.
I had used “no presents” because we didn't need more things and I wanted the invitation to feel easy. I hadn't thought through what we'd do if someone brought one anyway, especially in front of children who had followed the request.
We thanked the child and put the parcel aside without opening it during the party. I didn't announce an exception or ask the guest to explain what their parent had decided.
Afterward my son still wanted an answer. I said the request was meant to remove an obligation, not create a test we would use to turn a guest away. He asked why we hadn't written that.
It's a fair criticism of my very short invitation.
We haven't opened the box yet. I'm deciding how to acknowledge it without making the gift the afternoon's most important event. My son would like to keep the wrapping paper, which is currently the part of this exchange he understands best.