Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Sports ·

We elected a captain by raising hands, and everyone looked at the old captain first

Sports category photographSports

I raised my hand for the new candidate only after checking whether the outgoing captain was watching.

Our adult volleyball team needed someone to take over. Two players volunteered. One was the old captain's closest friend. The other had offered a clear plan for sharing decisions and had quietly handled plenty of problems already.

We voted in a circle after practice. The old captain put his hand up immediately for his friend. Other hands followed. I saw two people hesitate before joining them. The second candidate smiled and said she was happy to help either way.

Afterward, three teammates told me they had preferred her. I said I had too, then admitted I had not voted that way. We all sounded strangely relieved to confess to one another instead of to the person who had stood there losing.

I am not demanding another vote because I dislike the result. I want the next one to be private. I also owe the candidate something better than telling her she would have won if people like me had been braver.

For now I have volunteered for one of the jobs she had proposed sharing. It is a small way to stop my agreement existing only in the parking lot.

Discussion

5 community replies

You cannot know how everyone would vote privately, but you do know your own raised hand did not reflect your preference. That is enough to question the method.

Exactly. Keep the request for a private vote grounded in what you experienced, rather than claiming a different result was guaranteed.

An open vote is not automatically coerced. The friendship and timing made it difficult here, and a private ballot would reduce that pressure next time.

Telling the losing candidate she secretly had supporters could ask her to comfort the people who did not support her when it mattered.

Offer the shared-job idea to the new captain too. It can still improve the team without requiring the losing candidate to carry the whole repair.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Sports

Explore more Sports stories →