Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

We asked which apartment he liked after we'd already chosen one

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old voted for the apartment with the little balcony. My husband and I exchanged a look.

We had already agreed on the other one. We'd brought our son to see both and asked what he thought because we wanted him included. Apparently we'd offered participation in a decision whose answer was already in our messages.

When we told him which place we'd chosen, he asked why his vote didn't count.

I said adults had to make the final decision. He said I hadn't asked which place he'd recommend to the adults. I'd asked which one we should get.

There were practical reasons for our choice, and I can explain them without giving him every detail of the household finances. None of those reasons changes the question I actually put to him.

I told him I should have explained what was still open for discussion. He asked whether choosing where his bed went would be another pretend decision.

I said we'd look at the room first and tell him what would fit before asking. I didn't promise he could put every piece of furniture anywhere to make up for the earlier vote.

He still likes the balcony apartment better. I haven't asked him to describe the new place as exciting so we can feel that he's been successfully included.

For now he wants to know where the bookcase can go. That's a real question we can take a tape measure to answer.

Discussion

5 community replies

He noticed the difference between giving an opinion and casting a vote. Including him wasn't the problem; concealing which kind of participation was available made the answer feel rigged.

The adults can retain the housing decision. You don't have to give him a replacement veto to acknowledge that the question implied more influence than he had.

For the room layout, establish the actual constraints before presenting options. That lets the next choice be real without having to be unlimited.

And let him prefer the other apartment while making those choices. Enjoying the bookcase plan doesn't need to become proof that the original disappointment has vanished.

Had you told him any of your practical reasons before the viewings, or did he hear them only after his choice lost? That affects what explanation he is missing now.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →