Two children recognized the same water bottle in lost and found
ParentingMy seven-year-old pointed into the lost-and-found bin and said he'd found his bottle. Before I reached it, another child said it was hers.
They were the same color. Both had rubbed places on the bottom. My son's name had washed off his old label; this bottle had a pale rectangle where a label might have been.
I said I recognized the dent. Then I looked again and wasn't sure whether I actually did.
I'd spent weeks telling him to be more responsible about the missing bottle. Now I wanted him to have successfully found it, preferably before I bought another one.
The other child was equally certain. I don't know what evidence she had beyond the matching color, because I hadn't asked her anything before announcing my recognition.
We left the bottle with the staff member managing the bin and asked how they wanted the uncertainty handled. I didn't tell either child the school's answer before someone who knew it had spoken.
My son was furious with me on the walk home. He said I'd wanted him to find it and then wouldn't let him take it.
I said finding a matching one wasn't the same as knowing it was his. He said I'd said it was.
That is the part I need to correct clearly. I became certain out loud before I had earned the certainty, and he was the person left carrying the reversal.