The whiteboard-marker cap stayed in the cup and exposed the trick
Funny/WTFI grabbed a black marker from the meeting-room cup and started writing. The first line appeared on my fingers instead of the board.
The marker cap was still standing upright in the cup. I had lifted the barrel cleanly out of it because the cap fit tightly between two other pens.
I capped the marker, cleaned my hand and chose another one.
The pen cup had performed the smoothest uncapping trick in the building and left me holding all the evidence.