The villain in my daughter's story makes everyone clean their room
ParentingMy eleven-year-old let me read a story she wrote. The villain wears slippers, drinks tea and interrupts adventures by asking whether anyone has put their clothes away.
I asked whether the villain was me.
She said the villain had a castle. We have a townhouse.
I laughed, then kept reading with the unpleasant sensation of recognizing my own dialogue in somebody else's mouth.
The story is funny. The children escape through a laundry chute, which our house also lacks. There is a dragon who sorts socks badly. I would ordinarily enjoy all of this.
Instead I am tempted to ask why the parent-like character never does anything kind.
My daughter didn't offer the story as a statement about our relationship. She asked whether I thought the ending made sense. I have no evidence that every fictional complaint is something she has been unable to say aloud.
I also know she sometimes finds my reminders irritating. That doesn't make the plot an emergency or make me entitled to demand a nicer role.
I told her the ending was clear, and asked about one part I genuinely didn't understand. She explained it. Then she asked if I wanted to read the next story.
I said yes.
Now I need to decide whether to mention that I recognized a few lines or simply let her have a comic villain. I don't want reading with me to become a price she pays by explaining her feelings afterward.
The next story has a mayor. I have been informed that the mayor also wears slippers, but this time the slippers are evil.
