Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Neighbours ·

The vegetable contest judged the gardener as well as the tomatoes

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Our garden held a blind tomato tasting. I numbered the plates so nobody knew which plot supplied each sample. After the votes were counted, the coordinator asked me to swap the names beside first and second place.

The actual winner was a new gardener who rarely attends workdays. The runner-up has volunteered for years. The coordinator said the little prize should recognize commitment, not just a lucky harvest.

I refused to change the list. Now he says I care more about tomatoes than the people who keep the garden going. I thought that was the point of a tomato tasting.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the tasting result as counted and suggest a separate volunteer recognition. The stated competition and the service award measure different things.

Were workday contributions ever included in the announced judging criteria? If not, adding them after the votes would change what entrants thought they were entering.

Long-serving volunteers may deserve more appreciation than they receive. Quietly moving someone else’s name off first place would not provide honest recognition.

The coordinator can thank the runner-up publicly for the workdays without taking away the new gardener’s tomato result.

A blind tasting is a strange amount of preparation if the winner was supposed to be chosen by attendance all along.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Neighbours

Explore more Neighbours stories →