The tamper ring made the bottle cap spin without opening
Funny/WTFI twisted the cap on a new bottle and felt it turning normally. It kept turning.
One bridge on the plastic tamper ring had not separated. The cap rotated, but the ring rotated with it and held the cap against the bottle neck like a tiny carousel with no exit.
I set the bottle down and opened it according to the package directions instead of pulling harder.
For thirty seconds I had excellent rotation, strong hand participation and absolutely no progress toward a drink.