Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

The student I interviewed liked the article until she saw her own complaint in quotation marks

Education category photographEducation

She read the draft twice and asked me to replace the sentence about the cafeteria line with “everything is fine.”

The complaint was what she had said. It was also sharper on the school newspaper page than it had sounded between friends after lunch.

I am writing this piece for journalism class. I had promised to check the quotation for accuracy, not offered to let someone rewrite the whole account. But I had never explained that distinction to her, and now accuracy sounded like a rule I was inventing because I liked the dramatic line.

Before submitting, I am taking the request to our teacher editor. We need to discuss what she understood the interview was for, whether the quote is necessary, and how the class handles a source who wants to change it.

I can report the long queue without pretending this one sentence is irreplaceable. I also cannot publish a new quotation she never said just to keep our friendship comfortable.

Discussion

5 community replies

Did she know she was speaking for a school newspaper piece when you asked? That context matters before the class decides how to handle her request.

Seeing casual words in print can feel different from saying them. Taking that reaction seriously does not require pretending the original quotation was inaccurate.

Checking whether words were recorded correctly and deciding whether to include them are different decisions. Both deserve attention here.

The most dramatic line is not automatically the most necessary one. Explain what the quotation adds before defending it as essential to the article.

If the same point can be established another appropriate way, that changes the editorial choice. The teacher can help assess the options without inventing a replacement quotation.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →