Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

The recommendation request began with a reminder of which student I was

Education category photographEducation

I attached my highest-scoring essay to the email and wrote, “I sat near the left window.” It felt like a weak opening for asking a professor to describe me.

I had done well in the course. I had also rarely spoken, never attended office hours, and assumed a good grade meant the instructor would have a detailed story ready when I needed one.

The application asks for a recommendation about how I work with others. My essay cannot answer that question by itself.

Before sending the request, I reread the instructions and thought about who has actually seen that part of my work. Another instructor supervised a small class project where I had to revise after a disagreement. That may be the more relevant person, even though the grade in that course was lower.

I still need to ask whether they are willing and have time. For once, I am choosing the witness to the work rather than the largest number on the transcript.

Discussion

5 community replies

The requested quality changes who can speak usefully. A strong essay and a high grade do not automatically show how you handle shared work.

Does the application specify which kinds of recommenders it accepts? Check that before deciding the project supervisor is eligible.

A lower grade does not make that instructor a worse choice if they can describe the exact kind of work the application asks about.

When you ask, include the prompt, deadline, and a brief reminder of the project. Let the instructor decide whether they can write a useful recommendation.

And leave room for no. Supplying the details should make the request answerable, not imply the letter has already been promised.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →