The political club deleted its meeting recording after a disputed vote
PoliticsOur political club voted on whether to endorse a ballot measure. The chair announced a one-vote victory, but two members said their online votes had not appeared. When we asked to review the meeting recording, the secretary said it had been deleted under the club’s new privacy policy.
The policy had never been circulated, and recordings from the previous six meetings were still online. The deleted file included the chair reading totals from the voting dashboard, not individual secret ballots.
We did not try to reconstruct votes from people’s comments. Instead, the board preserved the dashboard export, paused the endorsement, and scheduled a new vote with an independent teller. It also adopted a written retention schedule before recording the next meeting.
The second vote produced a clear three-vote margin. More importantly, nobody had to trust a disappearing file to know how it was counted.