Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

The no-phone dinner rule disappeared when Grandpa wanted the score

Parenting category photographParenting

My fourteen-year-old put her phone away when I asked. Five minutes later, my father took his out to check a game score.

I kept talking.

My daughter looked at his screen, then at me. I said Grandpa was only checking something quickly.

She said she had only been checking something quickly too.

I don't want dinner to become an inquiry into each person's screen use. I'd introduced a simple household rule, then quietly supplied an exception because challenging my father felt more awkward than correcting my child.

Dad hadn't heard the first request. He looked up and asked whether he was breaking a rule. I said yes, we'd asked for phones away during this meal. He put it down.

That part was much shorter than the explanation I'd been constructing for why it didn't need to happen.

Later my daughter asked whether adults could ever have exceptions. I said sometimes there would be a reason to discuss one. She asked why the score had counted before anyone discussed it.

It hadn't. I'd made it count in the moment because I wanted to avoid an uncomfortable sentence.

Next Sunday Dad will still be an adult I don't enjoy correcting. My daughter will still have noticed whether the rule becomes flexible only when somebody older wants their phone. I need to handle the actual exception, if there is one, before asking her to accept it as obvious.

Discussion

5 community replies

Your dad hadn't even heard the rule. Once you told him, he put the phone down. Much of the conflict came from the exemption you created before asking him anything.

A future exception could be reasonable without this score check having been one. You don't need an absolute rule for every possible dinner to admit what happened at this meal.

Explain that distinction before listing hypothetical emergencies. Otherwise the answer to her concrete question could disappear under exceptions nobody at the table needed.

Was her own check already underway before you announced phones away? That would make the quick-check comparison even more direct, though your account is clear about the unequal response either way.

She had complied and then watched you defend the same action from somebody else. It makes sense that putting Grandpa's phone away didn't instantly end the question she had about your part.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →