The main ingredient in our signature cocktail was discontinued
WeddingsOur signature cocktail uses a pear liqueur that the distributor discontinued after our tasting. The venue has enough for about thirty drinks, and we expect more than twice that number to order it.
The bar manager found two substitutes. One is sweeter and inexpensive; the other tastes closer but raises the drink cost by four dollars each. Mixing the remaining original bottles with a substitute could make the same named cocktail taste different from one guest to the next.
We could serve the original version only for a welcome toast and offer a revised drink afterward under a different name. That makes the limited supply feel intentional instead of quietly inconsistent.
My partner would rather pay for the close substitute and keep the menu simple. I care more about not discovering at the reception that the backup tastes nothing like our tasting.
Would you upgrade the substitute, redesign the cocktail or make the original a limited first round?