The magic-show volunteer put the trick coin in her pocket
EntertainmentA magician handed my sister a coin, closed her fingers around it and told her to “keep it safe until the end.” She took him literally and slipped her closed hand into her coat pocket.
While the magician distracted the audience, she opened her hand, found the coin still there and moved it into the pocket so she could clap. The trick depended on him retrieving that prepared coin during the next exchange.
He asked her to hold out her hand. It was empty. For one second, both of them looked equally astonished. Then he announced that she had performed the vanish and spent the rest of the routine trying to make an ordinary replacement coin reappear.
At the finale, he asked whether she had kept the first coin safe. She produced it from her pocket to the biggest applause of the evening.
She followed the instruction so carefully that she became the only person who knew where the magic had gone.