The gift-card envelope hid behind the greeting-card fold
Funny/WTFI handed over a birthday card and watched the recipient open it. The gift card was missing.
I checked the outer envelope, the table and my bag. Then the recipient flexed the greeting card flat. The small gift-card envelope slid from behind the center fold, where it had matched the white paper and stayed upright.
The gift had been inside the card the whole time, just not in any dimension visible to either of us.
I had managed to give someone suspense before giving them store credit.