The gas-cap tether sat in the threads and made the cap feel permanently wrong
Funny/WTFAfter refueling, I turned the gas cap and it stopped at an angle.
I backed it off and tried again. The cap still would not seat normally.
The flexible tether had fallen across the filler opening. Each time I turned the cap, its edge pinched the tether against the threads.
With the vehicle off and still parked at the pump, I moved the tether clear, inspected the cap and tightened it according to the vehicle instructions. It seated and clicked normally.
For thirty seconds I had treated the cap as a precision mechanical mystery. It was trying to close on its own leash.
Now I place the tether to the side before starting the cap. The tether is there to prevent loss, not to participate in installation.