The debate question lottery ignored every paper card
PoliticsOur forum promised to select audience questions by lottery. People could submit through a phone link or paper cards at the door. When the draw began, the moderator’s software randomized only the digital entries. The box of paper cards remained under the table.
Several older attendees had chosen paper after volunteers advertised both methods as equal. The producer said paper questions would be used only if the internet failed.
We stopped after the first question, numbered the paper cards, and added them to a combined draw. The first digital question remained, and all later selections came from the full pool.
The lottery was random inside the software. The unfairness happened one step earlier, when one path to the pool ended under the table.