Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

The date on the family photograph disagreed with the story I had already put in my report

Education category photographEducation

The back of the photograph said 1978. My draft said 1974, because that was the year my aunt remembered.

I wanted to erase the penciled note and keep the account I had already built around her story. Then I realized I was considering changing the evidence because changing two paragraphs felt inconvenient.

This is a school history assignment about one family object. Neither the photograph’s label nor my aunt’s memory explains the whole discrepancy. The writing on the back may have been added later. Her recollection may combine two occasions.

I have asked her what else she remembers and noted who supplied each date. If we cannot resolve it, I can say that in the report rather than presenting my preferred version as settled.

The photograph is now in a clear sleeve. The conflicting numbers remain visible. Apparently my first useful discovery was not the story I expected to confirm.

Discussion

5 community replies

You have two sources with different dates, not one proven date and one proven mistake. Keeping their origins visible is the important first distinction.

Does anyone know when the note on the back was written? That may help assess it without assuming that pencil automatically outranks memory.

Keep the two dates in your research notes with the source beside each. Then the final wording can reflect what you actually managed to establish.

An unresolved discrepancy can still show careful historical work. You do not need to accuse your aunt of inventing the story to acknowledge uncertainty.

And her story may remain valuable even if one year changes. A source can be worth listening to without being correct about every detail.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →