Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

The citation was accurate. My claim about the book was not.

Education category photographEducation

My tutor asked where the book made the argument in my essay. I opened the article that quoted it and pointed to the paragraph I had read.

She asked whether I had read the book. I had not.

I had copied the publication details carefully and felt unusually confident about the reference. The citation looked complete while my knowledge of what it supported was secondhand.

The article’s author might have represented the book fairly. I had not checked. I had also written “the book demonstrates” when all I could honestly say was that this article described it that way.

Before submitting, I need either to consult the relevant original material or rewrite the claim around the source I actually used, following our course’s citation guidance. I am asking the tutor how to make that relationship clear.

My reference list will probably get shorter. For the first time, that feels like a possible improvement rather than evidence that I did less work.

Discussion

5 community replies

Accurate publication details establish which book exists. They do not establish that you checked the argument you attributed to it.

Can you access the relevant section of the original through your library? That would help determine whether checking or narrowing the claim is the practical next step.

Mark the sentences in your draft that depend on the quotation before repairing the reference list. The claim is where the misunderstanding reaches the reader.

Yes. A perfectly formatted repair would still miss the point if “the book demonstrates” stayed attached to something you had not checked.

You noticed it before submission and have a concrete way to make the source relationship honest. A shorter list can reflect better control of what you are saying.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →