The choir’s cough-drop bowl became an anonymous song-request box
Stories & ConfessionsOur choir keeps wrapped cough drops near the rehearsal door. I slipped a paper request into the empty bowl, and the director performed the song as a surprise. Members began adding requests beneath the candy. Soon folded notes were mixed with lozenges, including one criticizing a soloist by name. During a concert, a singer grabbed the note instead of a cough drop and opened it onstage. The director threw away the bowl and all unsigned requests. I liked giving quiet members a voice, but not a hiding place for cruelty. What should replace it?