The chef who made our tasting menu left before the wedding
WeddingsWe chose our caterer after a tasting where the chef adjusted several dishes personally. That chef has now left the company, three weeks before our wedding.
The replacement kitchen team made our entree for a final vendor meeting, and it was noticeably different: the sauce was sweeter, the vegetables were softer and the portion was smaller. The catering manager says the written recipe has not changed and normal event variation is expected.
We are not asking for every plate to match a tasting spoon exactly. The problem is that all three differences moved in the same direction and nobody acknowledged them until we did.
The caterer offered another sample with the executive chef present, but wants to charge for it because our contracted tasting is already complete. Changing caterers now is unrealistic.
Would you pay for the second tasting, request written preparation notes or treat this as ordinary variation and move on?