Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

The ceramics instructor wanted my collapsed bowl on the display table

Education category photographEducation

My bowl folded inward before it ever reached the class display. I pushed it toward the back of my shelf and hoped we could discuss somebody else’s work.

The instructor asked whether she could put it beside an earlier photograph so we could examine what had changed. I said yes, then wished I had asked for a minute.

I am taking this class for pleasure. I do want useful feedback. I did not expect my least successful object to become the most visible one in the room.

The discussion was kind and specific. Nobody called it a beautiful accident. We looked at the photograph, listened to the instructor, and made notes for another attempt.

Afterward, I told her I would like a little warning before being the example next time. She said that was reasonable.

I took the bowl home rather than leaving it for disposal. It is not a secret now, but that does not mean it needs to live in the front window.

Discussion

5 community replies

Agreeing to learn from the bowl did not mean you had to enjoy becoming the demonstration. Asking for warning leaves room for both reactions.

“Nobody called it a beautiful accident” sounds like a relief. Specific feedback can be kinder than finding a flattering story for the object.

Would a brief private discussion first have made the group comparison easier? That gives the instructor something concrete to change.

A minute to decide might have been enough. The request does not need to turn into banning all spontaneous classroom examples.

The class may learn a lot from an unsuccessful piece, but its usefulness does not remove the maker’s part in deciding how it is shown.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →