The campaign widened its crowd photo by duplicating the same people
PoliticsA campaign banner showed a packed gym behind its candidate. I recognized my red scarf near the left edge—and again near the right, beside the same man holding a paper cup. Several clusters of people had been copied to extend the crowd beyond the original frame.
The photographer said the designer used a background expansion tool to fit a wide website header. The campaign argued that the edit was decorative and did not add anyone in front of the candidate.
After I sent side-by-side crops, the campaign replaced the banner with the uncropped photograph and labeled a separate graphic as an illustration. It also added a review step for edits that generate or repeat people.
The rally had drawn a respectable crowd. The altered image asked those who attended to become visual evidence twice.