The babysitting hour ended before the grown-ups were ready to leave
ParentingMy sixteen-year-old agreed to watch her little brother in the next room during a family lunch. We agreed on an hour and an amount of money. After that, she had plans with a friend.
When the hour ended, she came to get us.
My brother had just started a story. I told her to give us a few minutes. Then dessert arrived.
She came back wearing her shoes and said her friend was outside.
I said leaving abruptly would look rude. She asked what time would have looked polite, since she'd already come at the time we'd chosen.
Nobody at the table had a particularly good answer to that.
I took over with her brother. She left twenty minutes later than planned. Later I offered to pay for the extra time. She said she wanted me to understand that the friend had waited, not only that the clock had kept running.
I'd treated the agreed hour as an estimate because the adult conversation wasn't finished. She had treated it as the point when she was free to leave.
She'll consider another arrangement, but she wants an actual adult handover at the end. I think that's reasonable. My husband thinks we should simply avoid booking her when she has plans afterward.
That would be easier for us. I'm not sure it answers why our end time only counted when there was nowhere else she wanted to be.